Feedback sites?

Can anyone recommend other sites to get tune feedback?

3 years ago

Cobra commander
mrpryde Pic

1140 Posts

talk to frank.

3 years ago

Matt Capitani
mattcapitani Pic

4732 Posts

In reply to
Can anyone recommend other sites to get tune feedback?

A certain professional decent label owner and producer gave me some good advice and said fuck bt just send them to the labels behind the scenes and get advice and feedback that way because if people have slated your tunes on the feedback forum it ruins the buzz for release on the label its coming out on thumbsup

Post edited by owner 02/07/2009 13:51:08

3 years ago

Cobra commander
mrpryde Pic

1140 Posts

Matt is right i was going to say what he said i thought the comedy card would be better laughing

3 years ago

Matt Capitani
mattcapitani Pic

4732 Posts

In reply to
Matt is right i was going to say what he said i thought the comedy card would be better laughing

lol

3 years ago

just send them to the labels behind the scenes and get advice and feedback that way

Good luck with that. Labels get tons of demos and unless you have something particularly special you'll be lucky to get any sort of response.

Besides, sometimes I just want some opinions on an idea. I don't want to waste 30 hours on a tune if people think it's cack.

The irony of it all is that I used to run a website for music producers specifically designed to give quality feedback. Sigh.

3 years ago

Hardhouse / Hardtrance / Harddance

OPEUM

1634 Posts
London

try the feedback forum HERE mate ill give you some pointers if i can... thumbsup

3 years ago

4520 Posts

In reply to
just send them to the labels behind the scenes and get advice and feedback that way

Good luck with that. Labels get tons of demos and unless you have something particularly special you'll be lucky to get any sort of response.

Besides, sometimes I just want some opinions on an idea. I don't want to waste 30 hours on a tune if people think it's cack.

The irony of it all is that I used to run a website for music producers specifically designed to give quality feedback. Sigh.

dude that's just what you mums telling you, its not her fault she just can't bring herself to tell you you're crap wink

.

3 years ago

Matt Capitani
mattcapitani Pic

4732 Posts

In reply to
just send them to the labels behind the scenes and get advice and feedback that way

Good luck with that. Labels get tons of demos and unless you have something particularly special you'll be lucky to get any sort of response.

Besides, sometimes I just want some opinions on an idea. I don't want to waste 30 hours on a tune if people think it's cack.

The irony of it all is that I used to run a website for music producers specifically designed to give quality feedback. Sigh.

Is that what you call it??.. wasting 30 hours on a tune.. 2far well if you dont think youv got it theres no point you doing it sorry but its music mate not a race to the finish line thumbsdown

Maybe your just suited to running a music website then i dont know rolleyes

Post edited by owner 02/07/2009 16:13:11

3 years ago

Wow you guys are quite negative. frown

I don't get a lot of time to make tunes so I only want to invest that time on the most worthwhile ideas.

Maybe you could listen to some of my tunes before telling me I'm crap and should stick to running websites, LOL.

http://myspace.com/magnetiktrax

Opeum, thanks for the link, just signed up smile

3 years ago

4520 Posts

nobody told you that you were crap it was a joke hence the wink

at the end

3 years ago

3358 Posts

soundcloud.

get in

3 years ago

Cheers Miyagi, will sign up now.

opeum, signed up mate but not getting a confirmation email.

3 years ago

Hardhouse / Hardtrance / Harddance

OPEUM

1634 Posts
London

Check in your spam email mate, or pm me with your email that you signed up with and ill confirm you manually... thumbsup

P.S my soundcloud is www.soundcloud.com/opeum if you want to add me to your following list... supercool

Post edited by owner 02/07/2009 21:53:23

3 years ago

Athan James
jon Pic

3255 Posts

Nowhere

Deep House

just send to guys u know will give ya quality feedback dude...not here were most will go 'woooo thats sick'(only if they know u tho)...

Post edited by owner 2/07/2009 10:29:56 PM

3 years ago

Cobra commander
mrpryde Pic

1140 Posts

In reply to
just send them to the labels behind the scenes and get advice and feedback that way

Good luck with that. Labels get tons of demos and unless you have something particularly special you'll be lucky to get any sort of response.

Besides, sometimes I just want some opinions on an idea. I don't want to waste 30 hours on a tune if people think it's cack.

The irony of it all is that I used to run a website for music producers specifically designed to give quality feedback. Sigh.

why ask questions if you already know the answers to them?

3 years ago

In reply to

just send to guys u know will give ya quality feedback dude...not here were most will go 'woooo thats sick'(only if they know u tho)...

Well, I used to have over 100 producers in my MSN list but I can't log into the account any more. Basically I'm starting from scratch on the whole feedback thing.

SoundCloud is looking good. Me likes smile

3 years ago

Matt Capitani
mattcapitani Pic

4732 Posts

In reply to

In reply to
just send them to the labels behind the scenes and get advice and feedback that way

Good luck with that. Labels get tons of demos and unless you have something particularly special you'll be lucky to get any sort of response.

Besides, sometimes I just want some opinions on an idea. I don't want to waste 30 hours on a tune if people think it's cack.

The irony of it all is that I used to run a website for music producers specifically designed to give quality feedback. Sigh.

why ask questions if you already know the answers to them?

lol exactly magnetik you came on here asking for advice and as soon as i generously gave you some words of wisdom and well sought advice as soon as i opened my mouth BANG you contradicted me.... uhoh

3 years ago

lol exactly magnetik you came on here asking for advice and as soon as i generously gave you some words of wisdom and well sought advice as soon as i opened my mouth BANG you contradicted me.... uhoh

Sorry if I offended you, that wasn't my intention. I just don't want to deal with labels, especially when I'm looking for feedback on unfinished tunes.

3 years ago

Matt Capitani
mattcapitani Pic

4732 Posts

In reply to

lol exactly magnetik you came on here asking for advice and as soon as i generously gave you some words of wisdom and well sought advice as soon as i opened my mouth BANG you contradicted me.... uhoh

Sorry if I offended you, that wasn't my intention. I just don't want to deal with labels, especially when I'm looking for feedback on unfinished tunes.

Its cool mate the thing is on bt feedback people will try and pick the slightest faults on clips you show them just because most of them want to appear inteligently critical or just plain sarcastic and some generally constructive

ive always taken the constructive critisism on board but to the sensitive producer bt can be fucking annoying on your productions and the way you see them after some big twat has gone "it sounds the cowbells overpowering the rest of da tune and the bass notes are an inch long they should be an inch and 2mm long" then go back to your own productions not really giving a shit what they said but conciosly in the back of your mind thinking theres something not quite right with the cowbell no matter what you do to it thumbsup

3 years ago

ive always taken the constructive critisism on board but to the sensitive producer bt can be fucking annoying on your productions and the way you see them after some big twat has gone "it sounds the cowbells overpowering the rest of da tune and the bass notes are an inch long they should be an inch and 2mm long" then go back to your own productions not really giving a shit what they said but conciosly in the back of your mind thinking theres something not quite right with the cowbell no matter what you do to it thumbsup

Heh, I know what ya mean. Forums aren't great for feedback to be honest. Half the time people get into an argument on your thread or go off on a tangent about what they got up to at the pub last night. That's why I started my music producer site, so producers could get decent feedback. SoundCloud is kinda what I wanted it to become, but with more emphasis on being a mix of what SoundCloud is and a music mag like Computer Music.

Anyway I'm enjoying digging in deeper on SC. If anyone here wants to follow me or me to follow them my page is:

http://soundcloud.com/magnetik

3 years ago

Cobra commander
mrpryde Pic

1140 Posts

a good producer doesn't need feedback

3 years ago